Neural Network Model Selection Using Asymptotic Jackknife Estimator and Cross-Validation Method
نویسنده
چکیده
Two theorems and a lemma are presented about the use of jackknife estimator and the cross-validation method for model selection. Theorem 1 gives the asymptotic form for the jackknife estimator. Combined with the model selection criterion, this asymptotic form can be used to obtain the fit of a model. The model selection criterion we used is the negative of the average predictive likehood, the choice of which is based on the idea of the cross-validation method. Lemma 1 provides a formula for further exploration of the asymptotics of the model selection criterion. Theorem 2 gives an asymptotic form of the model selection criterion for the regression case, when the parameters optimization criterion has a penalty term. Theorem 2 also proves the asymptotic equivalence of Moody's model selection criterion (Moody, 1992) and the cross-validation method, when the distance measure between response y and regression function takes the form of a squared difference.
منابع مشابه
On Optimal Data Split for Generalization Estimation and Model Selection
Modeling with flexible models, such as neural networks, requires careful control of the model complexity and generalization ability of the resulting model. Whereas general asymptotic estimators of generalization ability have been developed over recent years (e.g., [9]), it is widely acknowledged that in most modeling scenarios there isn't sufficient data available to reliably use these estimato...
متن کاملJackknife Model Averaging for Quantile Regressions
In this paper we consider the problem of frequentist model averaging for quantile regression (QR) when all the models under investigation are potentially misspecified and the number of parameters in some or all models is diverging with the sample size To allow for the dependence between the error terms and the regressors in the QR models, we propose a jackknife model averaging (JMA) estima...
متن کامل"Technical Report" Performance Comparison of IHACRES Model and Artificial Neural Network to Predict the Flow of Sivand River
The accurate determination of river flow in watersheds without sufficient data is one of the major challenges in hydrology. In this regard, given the diversity of existing hydrological models, selection of an appropriate model requires evaluation of the performance of the hydrological models in each region. The objective of this study was to compare the performance of artificial neural network ...
متن کاملPrincipled Architecture Selection for Neural Networks: Application to Corporate Bond Rating Prediction
The notion of generalization ability can be defined precisely as the prediction risk, the expected performance of an estimator in predicting new observations. In this paper, we propose the prediction risk as a measure of the generalization ability of multi-layer perceptron networks and use it to select an optimal network architecture from a set of possible architectures. We also propose a heuri...
متن کاملValidation and Verification
This chapter discusses important aspects of the validation and verification of neural network models including selection of appropriate error metrics, analysis of residual errors and resampling methodologies for validation under conditions of sparse data. Error metrics reviewed include mean absolute error, root mean squared error, percent good and absolute distance error. The importance of inte...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 1992